Research Article |
Corresponding author: Marcus Bevilaqua ( marcusbevilaqua@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Kristina von Rintelen
© 2020 Marcus Bevilaqua.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Bevilaqua M (2020) Guide to image editing and plates diagrammaking for scientific publications with an emphasis on taxonomy. Zoosystematics and Evolution 96(1): 139-158. https://doi.org/10.3897/zse.96.49225
|
Figures for scientific publications go through various stages from the planning, to the capturing of images, to the production of finished figures for publication. This guide is meant to familiarise the reader with the main image-editing software used by professional photographers. The guide’s focus is on digital photo editing and the production of figures using Adobe Photoshop to produce publication-quality figures for scientific publications. This guide will be of fundamental use for the academic public, especially taxonomists and others who work with images. Besides, it should be useful for anyone interested in becoming familiar with the basic tools of image editing.
Adobe Camera Raw, Adobe Lightroom, Adobe Photoshop, cybertaxonomy, digital photography, image bank, software application, taxonomy
“One picture is worth ten thousand words.”
Confucius (Chiu Kung, 552–479 B.C.)
Within the world of scientific writing, the iconic phrase of Confucius is particularly true. A good researcher knows that the power of synthesis makes all the difference in scientific works, since, with the use of a single figure, it is possible to condense information contained in several paragraphs (
In academia, we incorporate images and figures in most scientific output formats such as lectures and workshops, handouts, papers, books, websites and other free or commercially-distributed digital teaching resources (
Especially in taxonomic works, the figures contained in publications are also part of the results. They must also be of good quality, clear and self-explanatory and they must comply with the requirements of the journal.
From the use of figures in a taxonomic work, it is possible to illustrate and catalogue taxa, detail their morphological characteristics and, based on these figures, to create a database combining the graphic information with character descriptions, creating value for researchers in various fields of science, such as anatomy, cytology, ecology, morphology, taxonomy and systematics.
Figures are arrangements of photographs or illustrations for publication, consisting either of one or several components (composite figures). Photographs, which are often the method of choice for illustrating organisms and their structures, are often indispensable. Photographs show the real appearance of organisms, such as the colouring of a bird or insect, the texture of a reptile’s skin or the grooves and sutures on the integument of an arthropod. Photographs arranged into figures serve to emphasise structures, such as the venation of the wings of a dipteran or the shape of the chelicerae of an arachnid or gather a set of similar species or characters for comparison. Illustrations (drawings) are also quite important (not just) for taxonomy; however, the increasing sophistication and speed of scientific photography is leading to a replacement of drawings by photographs even in classical strongholds of the former, such as depictions of aedeagi in entomology (see, for example,
When an image is captured by the photographic equipment, the file is saved by the camera in a “raw” format. Any adjustments of brightness, contrast and white balance must be done subsequently and, frequently, researchers are not aware of (the need to apply) editing methods or perhaps even lack any interest in this topic. If such steps are omitted on the often slightly darker “raw” image, this makes it difficult to see details and colouring; in addition, the photograph may contain more information than needed (e.g. an entire animal instead of just a particular character), which would better be removed by crop adjustment in order to focus on what we want to show; finally, some photographs can generally have undesirable elements that can distract the reader from an important feature. This type of image needs editing before preparing a figure and submitting the manuscript.
Editing of images for scientific publications is increasingly encouraged and plays a key role in the development of multimedia presentations (
Figures for scientific publications go through various stages from the planning, to the capturing of images, to the production of finished figures for publication. The aim of the present work is to familiarise researchers and students (even if they have no previous knowledge) with Adobe Photoshop, the main image-editing software used by professional photographers, to ensure that readers can easily find and use the tools and settings described and to use this software’s digital photo editing capacity to produce publication-quality figures for scientific publications.
Example images were taken using a Leica M165C stereomicroscope with a DFC295 camera attached, with image capture settings applied from the Leica Application Suite (LAS) version 4.2 software. For a uniform and more efficient illumination, a geodesic light dome was used according to
The name of each tool, its function and shortcuts were used according to the Photoshop User Guide (
The use of Photoshop in this work is divided into five steps:
After starting Photoshop, the input screen appears (Fig.
To open images in Photoshop go to “File > Open” or (Ctrl/Cmd + O). It will open a browser window and then select which photo you want to edit.
The Document window displays the file you are working on. Document windows can be tabbed and, in certain cases, grouped and docked. The Control Panel displays the options for the currently selected tool. The Tools contains tools for creating and editing images, artwork and page elements. The related tools are grouped together (Fig.
When starting Photoshop, the Tools appears on the left side of the screen. You can expand some tools to show the hidden tools. A small triangle at the bottom right of the Tools icon indicates the presence of hidden tools. View information about any tool by positioning the pointer over it. The tool name appears in a tooltip below the pointer.
This guide will cover the following tools (Fig.
The Photoshop Options bar changes according to each selected tool, making it very dynamic, so it is important to realise what properties each tool has. Here, we will use a lot of tools that behave like brushes, so it is important to point out that brush tools count on the increase of the radial dimension and shape and this can be done through the properties bar (Fig.
This area is fully adjustable; however, here we will focus on the use of four panels (Fig.
The native Adobe Camera Raw filter in Photoshop CC is similar to the Develop module in Lightroom (so it can be used in the same way) and lets you adjust the colour and tonal range of your photos, as well as crop photos and make other corrections.
The panels on the left side of Camera Raw allow you to select the photos, select and view them at various stages of editing and apply general presets. The centre of the panel provides a viewing and working area.
To open the Camera Raw filter (Fig.
If necessary, adjust the angle and framing of the photo to leave in the centre what is most important and what should be highlighted. To do so in the “Tool panel” (Fig.
There is no “cake recipe” in this step. Each photo should be treated as unique because the settings that are made on the camera reflect how images should be edited. One suggestion is to perform detailed control using the sliders provided for each setting.
However, there are ways to know when a photo is well edited or if it needs some tweaking. The first point is that scientific photos should portray the reality of the specimens or at least approach it. This issue can be solved mainly in colour-coded commands, since cameras often do not portray the colouring of specimens correctly. It certainly saves time if the white balance is already set on the camera before taking the photo(s); please refer to the camera user manual for the necessary steps. The second issue to consider is the good lighting of the photo. This is undoubtedly one of the greatest difficulties since not all have photographic equipment that already have good diffusers or lighting systems. Thinking about this,
With the “Basic” panel (Fig.
The “HSL / Grayscale” panel (Fig.
It is very important to be careful in this part of the editing, because modifying image colours very differently from the original can be seen as fraud in many scientific publications and even harm the readers of your publication. For example, if you say that a bird has a yellowish colour, you should leave those tones with little modification, as yellow may turn orange, thereby conflicting with what you state in your publication. Common sense is recommended at this stage.
After editing the image, if you are not satisfied with the result, re-do any of the previous steps no matter what order you follow. However, if the result pleases you, just click “OK” and the image will return to the Photoshop workspace.
Many scientific photos have spots, smudges, spots of light or shadow that, although they do not impair (in some cases) the interpretation of the characters, make the image visually and aesthetically less attractive. It is common in the study of insects that the images contain pieces of other organisms, dust, dirt particles, amongst other elements, that can be considered unwanted. Removal of these elements is often seen as “over-pricing” or “wasting time”; however, in most international journals, image (and overall figure) quality is taken into account and is often one of the reasons reviewers request that a manuscript is reviewed again. However, as outlined above, it is crucial to avoid modifying the original image(s) beyond removing distractions from the relevant object or increasing their aesthetic value. Any measures that change the object in an arbitrary way may constitute image fraud or be regarded as such (
In the picture below (Fig.
Again, it is important to avoid unintentional deletion or modification of structures in depicted specimens. After this step, the image will be clean and aesthetically more acceptable since the reader will be able to view in a simpler way without dirt stains or points of light and unnecessary shadows, which can disrupt the interpretation of the structures in the bidimensional plane (Fig.
After removing all undesirable elements from the image, it’s time to improve the aspect of the background. The best way to do this is to eliminate the original background of the image by leaving it transparent or by placing another background, which usually has a different colour. In many cases, just blurring the background is not enough or the researcher would like to add a new colour to the background of the image. For this, you must delete the desired area using three tools: “Magic Wand”, “Lasso” and “Eraser”. Note in the image below (Fig.
After cleaning the spots, it’s time to remove the background of the image by using two similar methods: Magic Wand or Lasso. You may feel at ease to use just one method or both. 1. Select the “Magic Wand” tool (W); 2. Unlock the image layer by clicking on the padlock icon next to the layer name; 3. Click the region you want to delete. Note that one area has been selected (Fig.
To use the Lasso Tool, do the following: 1. Select the “Lasso” tool (L); 2. Unlock the image layer by clicking on the padlock icon next to the layer name; 3. Contour it in the region to want to keep so that it is selected; 4. Right-click and select “select inverse” (Shift + Ctrl/Cmd + I); 5. After selecting the region (Fig.
Click the “Eraser tool” (E) and select the first tool in the group, adjust the size of the brush so that it is an ideal size and move throughout the region you want to erase. The most important tip for working with the Eraser tool is the size and hardness of the brush. It is recommended that you use an increased zoom along with a medium hardness by about 30 to 50%. Another use of the Eraser tool is the “Background eraser tool” to delete more homogeneous areas, as it can clear large areas of the background with just one click.
After removing the background of the image (Fig.
A very important detail, but what makes a difference when working in Photoshop, is to pay attention to which layer you are working on and which layer should be on top or under. In this case, the new layer with the new background will be below the layer that corresponds to the structure being edited. 2. Select the “Paint Bucket tool” (G) and then choose which colour you want your new image background to have. To do this, click the “Colours” tool and select the desired foreground colour (Fig.
After removing undesirable elements in the image and making the appropriate background, it is time to finalise the image by adding elements that will compose the photo that will be present on the figure. Such elements are important in taxonomic works because they make the structure more evident, indicate regions of interest or represent dimensions of the anatomical piece, such as the scale. Let’s divide this step into two: pointing structures and applying the scale in the photo.
In scientific publications, the disclosure of certain structures, regions or details in the photo are indispensable for the researcher to be able to pass on the correct information to the reader and to make the image appreciation and interpretation easier. That is why it is very common to use certain devices that highlight certain regions in the image, such as the use of arrows or polygons. This step can also be done during the preparation of figures, that is, when each photo is added to the figure, the highlighting tools are applied.
1. In the Shape tools group (U), select the one that suits you best (Fig.
Another element present in scientific figures is the scale bar. The scale bar reflects the mathematical relationship between the dimensions of the object in the real state and that of the image that represents it. It is one of the essential elements of images of minute organisms or structures, along with orientation and legend.
Usually, taxonomists, such as entomologists, arachnologists and malacologists, use special equipment to take pictures with, for example, a stereomicroscope coupled to a camera with extended and stacked focus. This equipment with their (usually proprietary) software already provides the scale bar along with the final image, otherwise the scale has to be inserted manually. The scale bar that is provided by the software or manually may also not be suitable for the target journal, as the publisher provides detailed instructions for making it. Here’s how to add the scale bar to comply with the journal’s pattern.
There are two very simple ways to create scale bars, one using selection tools and another using the pen tool. In this example, we will use a photo that was already exported with the scale bar, but it is not in the pattern required by the journal. First open the image containing the scale bar in File > Open or Ctrl/Cmd + O, then create a new layer (Ctrl/Cmd + Shift + N). First let’s follow the process using the selection tool (Fig.
The next step is optional, because some journals do not accept the text of the scale to be plotted together with the image and require it to be placed in the legend. However, let’s deal with this step, because some allow or even require such formatting. 1. Select the Horizontal Text Tool (T) and click on the image; 2. In the properties bar, change the text formatting according to your wish (Fig.
Now the image is already completely edited, “clean”, with the elements that show structures and with the scale. Save this image to continue editing other images or to start composing the figure. To save, click on File > Save As or Ctrl/Cmd + Shift + S; choose the folder in which you want to save the image and select the Photoshop file type whose extension is .psd then click Save. The image is saved and ready to be used again when needed. The file format .psd is not mandatory, since you can choose many other formats including the widely used .jpg, .png or .tif formats. However, it is strongly advised to use the Photoshop or .tif format with the ‘layers’ option on to facilitate the later editing of separate elements composing the final photo, such as highlighting markers and scale bars. You should also note that some file formats include the commonly used .jpg format-reduced file size through image compression. This always involves a reduction of quality, even when the highest available quality (thus the lowest reduction in file size) is chosen. Quality will be reduced every time a .jpg file is saved and this can significantly diminish the quality of your final image. Such file formats should not be used for saving images that are likely to be further processed (see below in the section on saving a figure for more details on file formats and compression).
In scientific publications, journals give preference to the presentation of the images by means of composite figures or plates, instead of single photos, since this way of presenting their results contains more information in a smaller space, besides gathering in the same image photos of several structures of the same organism or the same structure belonging to several different taxa.
Here, I present a quick and easy method of composing figures, which can contain multiple images in a single figure. Initially, one must be careful in what resolution and size the journal requires for the images. First, it is necessary to understand that most journals currently publish their papers in two ways: online and printed, that is, there are two different resolutions: video display and print display.
Video projection is a relatively low-resolution system and print is a relatively high-resolution system, which means that most new monitors have a resolution of 96 dpi (however, a resolution of 72 dpi must be assumed if you want images for distribution online), whereas modern printers print at a minimum at 300 dpi; consequently, the video projected image derived from a 72 dpi digital image file looks pretty much the same as the projected image of a 300 dpi file. In contrast, there is a very noticeable difference in the quality of a print derived from a 72 dpi digital image file compared with a print of a 300 dpi image file (
A copy of any image or figure should be kept at the original resolution or a reasonable maximum resolution of 1,200 dpi if the file is otherwise far too large. It is always possible to reduce the resolution to 300 dpi, but it is not possible to enlarge a 300 dpi image or figure to 600 dpi without a noticeable loss in quality. Keep in mind that you may start off by submitting your manuscript to a journal that only requires 300 dpi pixel images, but could end up at a journal demanding a higher quality. The same is true for the maximum size of figures, which should not be reduced in the original figures to meet the demands of a specific journal. Commonly, most journals require at least a resolution of 300 dpi; however, the maximum image size is variable. Here, I will adopt the common size of an A4 sheet and 300 dpi resolution.
In the Photoshop workspace: 1. Create a new document (Ctrl/Cmd + N) and choose the desired options that are available in the dialogue box that will open (Fig.
Create new document dialogue box. A. Guide containing some presets with document sizes; B. Selected document; C. The name of the file to be created; D. File dimensions (can be expressed in millimetres, centimetres, inches or pixels); E. Orientation of the document (portrait, landscape or square); F. Resolution of the document to be created.
Note that the images are in disproportionate and undesirable sizes for the figure, so it is recommended that you adjust the size of the images as you drag them on to the figure. To do this, simply click on Ctrl/Cmd + T and resize them in a desirable way and then press Enter to confirm the modification. Again, it is important to only decrease the size of the single images and not blow them up. Keep copies of the images in their original format. Another crucial consideration is always to re-size images or figures proportionally, i.e. not just to reduce one dimension and thus distort proportions. After all the images have been re-sized, it is time to organise them so that all the elements are well arranged on the figure. A practical way is from the use of “guides”. The guides are horizontal and vertical lines that demarcate certain areas within a document. To create a guide, just click and drag on one of the rulers of the document (if the rulers are not visible, click View > Rulers or Ctrl/Cmd + R). Once you have created the guides, adjust them to position all the images on the figure (Fig.
Since the figure is a set of images, they must be numbered so that there is no confusion at the moment of quoting them within the body of the text. Some authors prefer to leave the text “loose” within the image, while others prefer to place the text inside a polygon (or any other shape) for better visualisation. See how to proceed: I suggest creating a new group of layers called “Letters”. In this group will be the layers that will be part of the numbering of each image inside the Figure
After completing all procedures, the figure is complete (Fig.
I will comment briefly on the characteristics and use of each of the four types of image file formats, mentioned above. For more details, I suggest consulting the works of
The Tagged Image File Format or TIFF (.tif) was created primarily by imaging developers of input and output devices, such as printers, monitors and scanners and, as a result, it is specifically designed to be compatible with different image processing devices. TIFF files can support a full range of image sizes, resolutions and colour depths and different compression technologies can be applied, including lossless compression with the LZW algorithm. Another useful feature of a TIFF file is that each file can contain more than one image, allowing the “layer” function within Photoshop. All these features make TIFF the standard file format for printed images. However, the large file size is the main disadvantage of this format.
The Portable Networks Graphics or PNG (.png) is a lossless compression format that is applicable for Internet use because of its small file size. PNG files use lossless compression performed by the LZW algorithm and gamma correction for cross-platform brightness consistency and RGB colour and variable transparency are supported. This flexible file format has several good features such fast image viewing, low file size and the option of maintaining transparent areas in the image (very useful resource for composing presentations for lectures), which make this file format excellent for images viewed on video devices, but it is not highly recommended as a printed image file format.
Joint Photographic Experts Group or JPEG (.jpg) is actually the compression algorithm used to create these files. It was created specifically for the storage and transmission of photographic images. The main advantage of this file format is its compressibility and resultant small file size which require significantly less storage space per image and allowing faster movement in the electronic environment. Consequently, it has become a standard for photos, also within, for example, PowerPoint presentations. The type of compression performed by JPEG allows genuine image compression, opposed to LZW compression. Unfortunately, this compression is “lossy”, meaning that there is loss of data in the compressed representation; therefore, users should save a JPEG file only once. This irreversible loss of data is the main disadvantage of JPEGs, as it may lead to an unacceptable level of image degradation.
In summary, you should always opt for a format using an algorithm (such as LZW) for lossless data compression that will not affect the quality of the figure. If the journal requires the submission of figures in .jpg format, keep a copy in a format meeting the former requirement.
As previously mentioned, the images presented in scientific publications are part of the results obtained by the researcher, mainly in taxonomic works, since the correct identification of the taxon depends on the description of this taxon along with good images that illustrate the diagnostic characters. With the advent of new technologies to represent specimens and their structures, there are publications containing techniques that promote different means of graphic representation, mainly by illustrations (
Unlike the illustrations that demand personal skills, specific abilities and considerable time expenditure (
Thinking about improving images for scientific publications and saving time, this guide provides a simple and quick way for anyone to edit photos to make them more attractive, both aesthetically and scientifically. The information provided here might be useful in many areas of the academic world, such as medicine, biomedicine, biology or chemistry, as well as for any person interested in such means as undergraduate, masters or doctoral students or even researchers or for any type of academic paper, such as dissertations, theses, scientific articles, event banners, oral presentations or explanatory folders.
I thank the reviewers who brought important considerations to the final version. This study was financed in part by the Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior – Brasil (CAPES) – Finance Code 001.